Securities and commodities brokers are one of the least happy careers in the United States.

At CareerExplorer, we conduct an ongoing survey with millions of people and ask them how satisfied they are with their careers. As it turns out, securities and commodities brokers rate their career happiness 2.7 out of 5 stars which puts them in the bottom 11% of careers.

To put this into perspective, we compared how happy securities and commodities brokers are to similar careers in the industry. Take a look at the results below:

Salaries and satisfaction ratings in similar careers

Career Satisfaction Avg Salary
Transportation planner
2.8
$84k
Bookkeeper
2.7
$46k
Logistician
2.7
$77k
Compensation and benefits manager
2.7
$128k
Account manager
2.7
$47k
Securities and commodities broker
2.7
$63k
Financial analyst
2.7
$92k
Compliance manager
2.7
$125k
Financial advisor
2.7
$94k
Cost estimator
2.7
$65k

So what does it mean to be happy in your career? Let’s break it down into different dimensions:

  • Salary: Are securities and commodities brokers happy with their salary?
  • Meaning: Do securities and commodities brokers find their jobs meaningful?
  • Personality fit: How well suited are people’s personalities to their everyday tasks as securities and commodities brokers?
  • Work environment: How enjoyable are securities and commodities broker’s work environments?
  • Skills utilization: Are securities and commodities brokers making the best use of their abilities?

Are securities and commodities brokers happy with their salary?

Securities and commodities brokers rated their satisfaction with their salaries 3.3/5. Few are explicitly unhappy with their salaries, with most securities and commodities brokers having generally positive views of their salary.

We asked securities and commodities brokers how fairly compensated they are for their work.
Their response was:

3.3 out of 5 stars

99 securities and commodities brokers

5 Star
22%

22% of securities and commodities brokers rated their compensation 5 stars

4 Star
27%

27% of securities and commodities brokers rated their compensation 4 stars

3 Star
23%

23% of securities and commodities brokers rated their compensation 3 stars

2 Star
14%

14% of securities and commodities brokers rated their compensation 2 stars

1 Star
13%

13% of securities and commodities brokers rated their compensation 1 stars

Do securities and commodities brokers find their jobs meaningful?

On average, securities and commodities brokers rate the meaningfulness of their work a 2.2/5. The majority of securities and commodities brokers struggle to find any sort of meaning in their work, likely resulting in less satisfaction with the career overall.

We asked securities and commodities brokers how meaningful they found their work.
Their response was:

2.2 out of 5 stars

97 securities and commodities brokers

5 Star
2%

2% of securities and commodities brokers rated how meaningful they found their career 5 stars

4 Star
13%

13% of securities and commodities brokers rated how meaningful they found their career 4 stars

3 Star
26%

26% of securities and commodities brokers rated how meaningful they found their career 3 stars

2 Star
23%

23% of securities and commodities brokers rated how meaningful they found their career 2 stars

1 Star
36%

36% of securities and commodities brokers rated how meaningful they found their career 1 stars

How well are people’s personalities suited to everyday tasks as securities and commodities brokers?

Securities and commodities brokers rated their personality fit with their work an average of 3.4/5. The majority of securities and commodities brokers find their personalities quite well suited to their work, with relatively few having complaints about their fit.

We asked securities and commodities brokers how well their personalities fit into their careers.
Their response was:

3.4 out of 5 stars

111 securities and commodities brokers

5 Star
19%

19% of securities and commodities brokers rated their career fit 5 stars

4 Star
37%

37% of securities and commodities brokers rated their career fit 4 stars

3 Star
21%

21% of securities and commodities brokers rated their career fit 3 stars

2 Star
11%

11% of securities and commodities brokers rated their career fit 2 stars

1 Star
13%

13% of securities and commodities brokers rated their career fit 1 stars

How enjoyable is a securities and commodities broker’s work environment?

As a whole, securities and commodities brokers rated their enjoyment of their work environment 3.2/5. Most of them tend to enjoy, or at least not be actively bothered by, their work environment.

We asked securities and commodities brokers how much they enjoyed their work environment.
Their response was:

3.2 out of 5 stars

109 securities and commodities brokers

5 Star
17%

17% of securities and commodities brokers rated their work environment 5 stars

4 Star
32%

32% of securities and commodities brokers rated their work environment 4 stars

3 Star
23%

23% of securities and commodities brokers rated their work environment 3 stars

2 Star
16%

16% of securities and commodities brokers rated their work environment 2 stars

1 Star
13%

13% of securities and commodities brokers rated their work environment 1 stars

Are securities and commodities brokers making the best use of their abilities?

Former securities and commodities brokers on CareerExplorer have rated their skills utilization 2.8/5. Securities and commodities brokers tend to feel that they don’t manage to use their abilities to their fullest, when compared to other careers.

We asked securities and commodities brokers how well their abilities were used in their careers.
Their response was:

2.8 out of 5 stars

112 securities and commodities brokers

5 Star
5%

5% of securities and commodities brokers rated their how well their skills were utilized in their career 5 stars

4 Star
30%

30% of securities and commodities brokers rated their how well their skills were utilized in their career 4 stars

3 Star
21%

21% of securities and commodities brokers rated their how well their skills were utilized in their career 3 stars

2 Star
24%

24% of securities and commodities brokers rated their how well their skills were utilized in their career 2 stars

1 Star
19%

19% of securities and commodities brokers rated their how well their skills were utilized in their career 1 stars